Atopic Dermatitis: a Short Summary
Comparative Efficacy and Safety of Ivermectin Cream 1% and Metronidazole 0.75% in the treatment of papulopustular Rosacea
Taieb A. et al
AAD 2015 Annual Meeting, San Francisco CA – United States
Methods
- 962 subjects enrolled
- evaluation of recurrence 36 weeks after
- study done over 16 weeks
- Evaluation of Rosacea severity in both treated groups (metronidazole 0.75% vs ivermectin 1%)
- Investigator Global Assessment (IGA): moderate to severe papulopustular Rosacea
- 15 to 70 facial papulopustular lesions (papules and pustules)
- 32 inflammatory lesions on average
- moderate rosacea (IGA of 3)
- Evaluation of results:
- blinded assessments at weeks 3, 6, 9, 12, 16:
- IGA
- inflammatory lesion counts
- adverse effects
- patient self-evaluation and questionnaire at week 16
Results
- Efficacy
- Statistically significant reduction of:
- inflammatory lesions (83% (Ivermectin) vs 73.3% (metronidazole) seen from week 12
- IGA of clear or almost clear (84.9% vs 75.4% of cases)
- patients reported excellent or good compared (85.5% vs 74.8%)
- 34.9% of patients on ivermectin were completely clear (vs 21.7% with metronidazole)
- Statistically significant reduction of:
- Safety:
- Adverse Events 32.4% for vs 33.1% (metronidazole)
- Related Adverse Events (2.3% vs 3.7%) (for related dermatological Adverse Events 1.9% vs 2.5%)
- Tolerability:
- stinging/burning (15.5% vs 11.1%)
- dryness (12.8% vs 10%
- itching (11.4% vs 8.8%)
Comments
- Ivermectin is available as a topical cream called Soolantra in the United States
- For the results:
- Although mentioned in the methods, the data concerning the recurrence was not published
- It might have been interesting to compare the efficacy with two other topicals used in the treatment of Rosacea: Brimonidine and Azelaic Acid
- There appears to be around 10% superior improvement rate with ivermectin compared with metronidazole.
- Also, the clearance rate is around a third of cases in ivemectin group vs a fifth in the metronidazole group
- For the safety:
- there is no mention of what the Adverse Events or Related Adverse events are
- there is no mention of the results being statistically different in Ivermectin vs Metronidazole
- Although written as a take home message, no conclusions can be made concerning safety (compared with metronidazole): although a small difference seems to appear, it has no statistically significant power
- For Acne, studies have compared oral treatments with oral treatments. It is interesting to note that this has NOT been done for Rosacea.
Contributors:
Dr Christophe HSU – dermatologist. Geneva, Switzerland
Related posts